The Slow Death of Finding Main Ideas in Fiction

“What’s the main idea of this story?”

It’s a question you rarely hear nowadays.

I’m not going to argue whether this is a good thing or a bad thing, but instead, I’d like to clarify why finding the main idea of fiction texts is waning from our curriculum. Four main trends are causing this:

  • The expansion of “theme” – When I went to high school, themes were loaded words like “respect,” “family,” or “hard work.” When asked for the theme of literature, one or two words was sufficient to name it. This is no longer the case. Today, themes resemble the morals of a story you can find at the end of Aesop’s fables. The Lion and the Mouse once had a theme of “caring,” but now it’s theme would be described as, “Don’t underestimate someone because they might be able to help you.” There’s no doubt this change has been fueled by the way theme questions are now asked on standardized tests.
  • A rise in the modes of writing – Distinguishing between narrative, expository, and persuasive writing has never been more important. We cycle between these types of texts both in our reading and our writing workshops. This has caused us to match certain skills and strategies with certain modes. Again, I’m not arguing whether this is good or bad, but textbook curriculums, standardized tests, and some professional readings tend to pair certain reading skills with a mode. Main idea gets paired with expository text.

100_8293

  • An emphasis on text evidence – Common core demands text evidence. Main idea demands text evidence (aka “supporting details”) as well. We now teach kids to find the specific sentences that support the main idea they have identified. This lends itself toward nonfiction texts. Finding sentences that support the main idea of a nonfiction text is also easier for test companies to develop into questions, especially the multi-answer questions we are seeing more often.
  • Less time for fiction – This connects with #2 and #3, but I wanted to clearly state this as its own point. As we spend more time with nonfiction, there is less time for fiction, and teachers must choose what lessons to keep and what to trim away. You can’t teach as many fiction lessons as you used to. So, if you are teaching theme and summarizing extensively, main idea in fiction hits the cutting room floor.

So what do you think? It the decline of teaching the main idea in fiction really happening or am I delusional? (Maybe both…) If it is happening, is it okay with you or not? Let me know what you think!

Advertisements

About mrwhitehb

I teach 4th grade and am the chair of the Young Hoosier Book Award Committee for grades 4-6.

Posted on September 30, 2015, in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. 1 Comment.

  1. I do agree there is a shift to nonfiction text due to common core and high stakes tests. Because so much of the testing includes nonfiction text we have had to make that shift in our classrooms as well. I’m not bothered by this change because it is providing more balance as well as an emphasis on how to tackle nonfiction text. When’s the last time a fiction book was required reading in life? That being said, fiction certainly has its place in the classroom.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: